Wednesday, March 21, 2012

There's no such thing as a free lunch...



DISCLAIMER: This following blog post doesn’t necessarily have much of anything to do with my adventures in Jordan, yet I happen to find it relevant.

My fellow ‘CIEE’ers and I are now amidst what we have been actively dreading for weeks: midterms.  Unlike my classmates, my grades do not ‘count’ towards anything of specific importance because I have graduated.  Indeed, I have graduated. And, yes many do ask, “so why are you doing this study abroad program that is specifically intended for undergraduate students…?” to which I reply, “Regardless of my recent graduation, I still want to pursue learning Arabic”—I know, it’s quite a profound thought….
At any rate, I am here to take full advantage of the opportunity to improve my Arabic skills, and expose myself to new subject matter.  Consequently, I am actually motivated to make high marks on my midterms.

I decided to take a course on the archeology of Jordan and Palestine due to the fact I know next to nothing about, uh, the importance and complexity of ‘rocks’.  However, I must confess I am a closeted classics nerd and I get exceedingly excited when discussing the Pax Romana.  Hence, my choice to take this course I believe was suitable.  In most respects, the class has been interesting—the professor is extremely knowledgeable and his vibrant passion for ‘rocks’ is contagious.

In preparation for the midterm, as expected, my class asked our professor on what specifically we should be expected to know for the test.  In an effort to condense the wide-ranging material we had covered, our professor requested to have a copy of someone’s notes.  This idea seemed to sit well with everyone at first, including myself.  Of course, the most extensive and finest notes were selected, and it was decided the test questions would be drawn from these notes exclusively (which was accepted as more than fair given we would be only responsible to know material that he had covered during his lectures).  But right as we were packing up our things to leave, our professor lastly added that every student in the class would also be given a copy of these notes.  Immediately, there was an onset of strong, yet mixed emotions unleashed within the classroom.  For those who had failed to take the proper notes which in turn would have enabled them to score a high mark on the midterm, this was relieving and fortuitous news.  On the other hand, the student who had just moments ago, ever so generously, offered her notes was dumbfounded.  I was astonished as well in realizing this simply meant the effort and hard work of this student alone was going to be utilized to advantage those who had consciously opted not to take as effective notes during class. 
In my opinion, this situation is rather amusing.  Clearly, the most gratifying aspect of scoring an ‘A’ on a test is the grade can only be accredited to the individual effort one spends preparing and studying.  I wonder how this decision of ‘leveling the playing field’ would influence the future work ethic of the students in my class?  Even if the ‘good note taker’ makes an ‘A’ on the midterm, will she no longer find it practical to take proper notes…?  Perhaps the ‘A’ she worked so hard to achieve will no longer be as rewarding in realizing those previously ‘unprepared’ students scored high marks solely due to her hard work.  If the ‘good note taker’ decides to stop taking notes because she doesn’t have any incentive to do the work for everyone else in the class, will there be motivation for the other students to begin taking good notes?  Will some students discontinue entirely from taking notes and being attentive in class just because they know someone else will be taking suitable notes from which they will be able to fully benefit in the future (and may feel entitled to fully benefit from), even though they don’t necessarily deserve it?

I know this may sound far-fetched and unrealistic but this silly situation highlights some interesting topics of discussion.  For example, clearly this situation could induce a 'free rider' problem.  Additionally, it exposes the intrinsic problems of collectivism.  I know ‘individualism’ has a negative connotation and common words associated with this term are selfish, greedy, self-centered, etc.  Nevertheless, the right of the individual is something I value dearly.  Okay, I am going to stop this blabber because I don’t want to turn this blog post into a lecture about one's moral right to pursue one's own interest and happiness—so I will just end it with a short quote from my favorite author.

"Collectivism requires self-sacrifice, the subordination of one's interests to those of others." Ayn Rand